Spin to Win Prize Ideas
That Convert
Discover the best prizes for your spin-to-win popup wheel. Learn probability settings, prize psychology, and design tips that maximize conversions.
The Psychology of Prize Wheels
Why gamified popups convert 3x better
Variable Rewards
Not knowing the prize creates more excitement than a guaranteed offer. The anticipation releases dopamine.
Earned Rewards
Winning feels earned even when everyone wins. This creates positive brand association and higher purchase intent.
Play Instinct
Humans are wired to play games. A spinning wheel is inherently engaging in ways forms aren't.
Prize Wheel Templates
Margin-Friendly Wheel
Best for stores with tight margins or premium products. Average effective discount: 7-8%
| Prize | Probability | Psychology |
|---|---|---|
| 15% Off | 5% | Jackpot - creates excitement |
| 10% Off | 15% | Great prize - feels like a win |
| Free Shipping | 30% | Popular - no margin impact |
| 5% Off | 35% | Common win - still valuable |
| Mystery Gift | 15% | Sample or small freebie |
High-Conversion Wheel
Best for stores prioritizing list growth and first purchases. Average effective discount: 12-15%
| Prize | Probability | Psychology |
|---|---|---|
| 25% Off | 5% | Mega jackpot - shareable |
| 20% Off | 10% | Major win - high conversion |
| 15% Off | 25% | Great prize - common enough |
| 10% Off | 40% | Standard discount - good value |
| Free Shipping + 5% | 20% | Combo prize - feels special |
No-Discount Wheel
Best for luxury brands or stores avoiding discount culture. Focuses on value-adds.
| Prize | Probability | Psychology |
|---|---|---|
| Free Product | 3% | Jackpot - specific item GWP |
| VIP Early Access | 15% | Exclusivity - no cost to you |
| Free Gift with Purchase | 30% | Added value - uses samples |
| Priority Shipping | 25% | Upgrade at low cost |
| Exclusive Content | 27% | Guide, video, or access |
Prize Wheel Best Practices
Optimize your wheel for maximum conversions
Mix high-value jackpots with common wins. Everyone should feel like a winner while protecting your margins.
Set exact odds for each prize. Give away big discounts rarely while making smaller wins common.
Color-code prizes by value. Make the wheel visually exciting with contrasting slice colors.
Add expiration to prizes. '24-hour flash prize' creates urgency to use the discount immediately.
Confetti, animations, and win messages that match the prize value. Big wins get bigger celebrations.
Track which prizes drive the most purchases. Optimize your wheel based on real conversion data.
Creative Prize Ideas by Industry
Fashion & Apparel
- • Early access to new collection
- • Free accessory with purchase
- • Double loyalty points
- • Free styling session
- • Anniversary collection preview
Beauty & Cosmetics
- • Free deluxe sample
- • Mini product bundle
- • Birthday gift upgrade
- • Free personalization
- • Virtual consultation
Home & Decor
- • Free interior design tips PDF
- • Priority delivery window
- • Free gift wrapping
- • Extended return window
- • Room planning service
Food & Beverage
- • Free tasting sample
- • Recipe ebook
- • Limited edition flavor access
- • Double quantity bonus
- • Subscription discount
Sports & Fitness
- • Free workout guide
- • Gear maintenance tips
- • Early access to sales
- • Free training video series
- • Membership trial
Pet Products
- • Free treat sample
- • Pet care guide
- • Double reward points
- • Free toy with purchase
- • Subscription starter kit
Prize Wheel Do's and Don'ts
Do This
- ✓Make every spin a winner
- ✓Use contrasting colors for slices
- ✓Add prize expiration dates
- ✓Celebrate wins with confetti
- ✓Send prize codes via email too
- ✓A/B test different prize mixes
Avoid This
- ✗"Try Again" or "No Prize" slices
- ✗Too many slices (keep to 6-8)
- ✗Similar colored adjacent slices
- ✗Complex redemption requirements
- ✗Prizes that feel worthless
- ✗Unrealistic jackpots (50% off)
Frequently Asked Questions
What prizes should I put on my spin to win wheel?
A balanced wheel typically includes: one 'jackpot' (20-25% off, 5% probability), several good prizes (10-15% off, 30% probability), common prizes (5-10% off or free shipping, 50% probability), and optionally a small consolation (mystery gift, 15% probability). Every spin should feel like a win.
How many slices should my prize wheel have?
6-8 slices works best visually and psychologically. Too few (4) feels limited, too many (12+) becomes cluttered and hard to read. 6 slices is ideal for mobile displays where screen space is limited.
Should every spin be a winner?
Yes, for maximum conversion. 'Try again' or 'No prize' outcomes frustrate visitors and reduce engagement. Instead, make the smallest prize something of value - even 5% off or a small gift with purchase makes visitors feel they won something.
What probability should I set for each prize?
A typical distribution: Jackpot (5%), Great prize (10%), Good prize (25%), Common prize (40%), Small prize (20%). This ensures exciting possibilities while keeping your average discount reasonable (usually 8-12% effective discount rate).
How do I prevent people from spinning multiple times?
Spur Popups tracks visitors by email, browser fingerprint, and session. Once someone spins, they can't spin again even if they clear cookies. The email submission happens before the spin, so you capture the lead regardless.
Do spin to win wheels actually work better than regular popups?
Yes. Spin-to-win wheels typically convert 2-3x better than standard newsletter popups (12-20% vs 3-8%). The gamification triggers dopamine and creates excitement that static forms can't match. The variable reward psychology is powerful.
Create Your Prize Wheel
Build a custom spin-to-win popup with your own prizes. Free to install, fully customizable, with probability control.
Start Building Free