Best Shopify Popup Apps
Compared
Looking for the best popup app for your Shopify store? We compare all major options: features, pricing, pros, and cons to help you choose the right one.
Top Shopify Popup Apps Compared
Side-by-side comparison of the most popular options
| App | Rating | Free Plan | Spin to Win | Auto Discounts | Starting Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spur Popups | ⭐ New | ✓ Generous | ✓ Included | ✓ Auto | Free |
| Privy | ⭐ 4.6 | ○ Limited | ○ Paid | ✗ Manual | $30/mo |
| Justuno | ⭐ 4.6 | ✗ Trial only | ○ Pro plan | ○ Complex | $29/mo |
| OptinMonster | ⭐ 4.3 | ✗ No | ○ Add-on | ✗ Manual | $9/mo |
| Wisepops | ⭐ 4.9 | ✗ Trial only | ✓ Yes | ○ Manual | $49/mo |
| Poptin | ⭐ 4.8 | ✓ Yes | ✗ No | ✗ Manual | $25/mo |
Detailed App Reviews
Spur Popups
Built specifically for Shopify with native integration. Includes spin-to-win, auto discount codes, and revenue tracking free. Creates Shopify customers that sync to any ESP.
Pros
- ✓ Free with generous limits
- ✓ Spin-to-win included free
- ✓ Auto Shopify discount codes
- ✓ Revenue tracking
- ✓ GDPR auto-compliance
Cons
- • Newer app, building reviews
- • Shopify only (not multi-platform)
- • No built-in email sending
Privy
Popular all-in-one solution with popups, email, and SMS. Good for stores wanting everything in one app, but features are more limited than dedicated tools.
Pros
- ✓ All-in-one solution
- ✓ Large user community
- ✓ Built-in email marketing
- ✓ Good Shopify integration
Cons
- • Spin-to-win costs extra
- • Manual discount setup
- • Limited free plan (100 contacts)
- • Email features basic vs Klaviyo
Justuno
Enterprise-grade popup platform with advanced features like AI product recommendations, complex workflows, and detailed targeting. Powerful but complex.
Pros
- ✓ Very powerful features
- ✓ AI product recommendations
- ✓ Advanced targeting rules
- ✓ Multi-platform support
Cons
- • Steep learning curve
- • Session-based pricing (overages)
- • No free plan (trial only)
- • Can be overwhelming
OptinMonster
Well-known popup builder that works across platforms. Good for WordPress users but lacks Shopify-specific features like auto discount codes.
Pros
- ✓ Low starting price
- ✓ Works on any platform
- ✓ Many template options
- ✓ Good A/B testing
Cons
- • No Shopify-specific features
- • No auto discount codes
- • Pageview limits on all plans
- • No free plan
Which Popup App Should You Choose?
Choose Spur Popups if...
- ✓You want the best free popup app
- ✓You need spin-to-win without paying extra
- ✓You want auto Shopify discount codes
- ✓You use Klaviyo/Omnisend for email
- ✓You want to track revenue from popups
Choose Privy if...
- •You want all-in-one popup + email
- •You don't have an ESP yet
- •You prefer fewer apps to manage
- •You're okay with basic email features
Choose Justuno if...
- •You need enterprise-level features
- •You want AI product recommendations
- •You have time to learn complex tools
- •Budget isn't a primary concern
Choose OptinMonster if...
- •You have multiple non-Shopify sites
- •You primarily use WordPress
- •You want lowest starting price
- •Shopify features aren't important
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best popup app for Shopify?
The best popup app depends on your needs. For most stores, Spur Popups offers the best value with free spin-to-win, auto discount codes, and no monthly fees. Privy is good for stores wanting all-in-one email + popups. Justuno suits enterprises needing advanced features. OptinMonster works for multi-platform businesses.
Are Shopify popup apps worth it?
Yes. Popup apps typically increase email signups by 300-500% compared to no popups or basic forms. The email list you build generates 20-30% of revenue for most stores. Even free popup apps provide significant ROI through increased subscriber capture.
Do popups hurt my Shopify store's SEO?
Not if implemented correctly. Google penalizes intrusive interstitials on mobile that appear immediately. Well-designed popups that trigger after delay, scroll, or exit intent don't affect SEO. All major popup apps handle this properly.
Can I use multiple popup apps?
Technically yes, but not recommended. Multiple popup apps can conflict, causing display issues and poor user experience. Choose one popup app and configure it to show different popups on different pages or for different triggers.
How do popup apps integrate with email platforms?
Most Shopify popup apps either directly integrate with ESPs (Klaviyo, Mailchimp, etc.) or create Shopify customers. Spur Popups creates Shopify customers with marketing consent, which automatically sync to any ESP connected to your Shopify store - no separate integration needed.
Try the Best Free Popup App
Spur Popups includes spin-to-win, auto discount codes, and revenue tracking - all free. See why stores are switching from paid alternatives.
Install Free